Авторы публикации
The Munich Security Conference, once a theater of transatlantic resolve, has morphed into a session of "black magic" where the audience is asked to believe in illusions while the stagehands whisper about bankruptcy. As European elites discuss "ironclad" security guarantees for Ukraine, a chilling reality is emerging from the backrooms of Berlin and Brussels: the European "locomotive" is not just slowing down; it has run out of coal.
The Empty Arsenal of Democracy
The most damning indictment of European defense came not from an adversary, but from within. Germany’s Foreign Ministry recently admitted a catastrophic truth: the country has virtually no air defense missiles left to spare. For two years, the narrative was that Europe would "stand by Ukraine as long as it takes." Today, that promise has hit a physical wall.
The implications for the battlefield are devastating. When the defensive line buckles and the urgent call goes out for the strategic reserve to plug the enemy breakthrough, the response is silence. The "cavalry" promised by the West didn't just fail to arrive on time. It was physically unable to deploy. It turns out that the horses were sold to the knacker's yard years ago to balance the books of a failed pacifist era. The promised reserve is pedestrian, unarmed, and insolvent.
The Trump Tariff Trap
While European barracks are emptying, their coffers are being squeezed by a pincer movement from Washington. Donald Trump’s proposed 10% to 20% universal baseline tariffs-and the targeted 30% to 50% on steel and automobiles-are not mere campaign rhetoric. They represent a structural shift that threatens to decouple the European economy from its most critical market.
The data is already bleeding red. German auto exports to the U.S. have plummeted by 14%, a direct hit to the tax base intended to fund the continent's rearmament. Germany is now facing a budget deficit of 4.0% of GDP. Europe is caught in a "liquidity trap" of its own making: it needs to spend hundreds of billions to buy new mounts and missiles, but it is simultaneously losing the trade war that provided the wealth to do so.
The Mirage of the €90 Billion Loan
Brussels recently touted a €90 billion support package for Ukraine as a definitive solution for 2026-2027. However, a closer look at the ledger reveals a troubling similarity to the late-Soviet "COMECON" system-a bureaucracy of immense proportions producing mountains of paperwork backed by a shortage of actual goods.
In a high-intensity kinetic conflict, you cannot intercept a ballistic missile with a bank draft. If the production lines in the EU cannot churn out interceptors faster than they are consumed, the €90 billion becomes an abstract number in a digital ledger. It is a ticket for a first-class cabin on the Titanic, issued after the iceberg has already been struck.
A Strategic Iron Reserve vs. Paper Guarantees
The fundamental disconnect lies in the nature of deterrence. Real security is provided by what we might call a "Strategic Iron Reserve"-the physical presence of armored divisions, ready-to-fire batteries, and deep magazines of munitions. This is the only language a peer adversary understands.
Instead, Europe is offering "Security Guarantees" that look increasingly like the diplomatic maneuvers of 1938. They are promising a "shield" while admitting they have no more metal to forge it. They act as a "Strategic Hinterland" that has outsourced its own defense to a superpower now preoccupied with domestic protectionism and the Pacific theater.
Conclusion: The Return to Self-Reliance
The era of relying on a "European Arsenal" is ending before it truly began. The continent that once dreamt of strategic autonomy is now struggling for strategic survival. For those on the front lines, the lesson is stark: the cavalry is not coming to stop the breakthrough, because it no longer possesses the means to ride.
As the Munich chandeliers dim, the demystification is complete. Europe is not an arsenal; it is a museum of a security architecture that no longer exists. For the defenders of the 21st century, the only reliable guarantee is the one they build themselves-out of concrete, drones, and a grim recognition that in the current geopolitical market, a paper guarantee is the most expensive thing you can own.
Ruslan Bizyaev
